About The Bentley Team

Our business objective is to provide knowledgeable market information helping people buy real estate and sell real estate in a stress free process from beginning to the closing table.

Why choose Peggy and Michael Bentley?
If you’re looking to buy or sell, increase your chances of success by using someone who has been successful.

We have been in the top 2% in Sales of Walworth County Realtors for the last decade. Celebrating our 14th year in business!

Meet the Team


Michael Bentley

From a farm in the small Scandinavian farming town of Spring Grove in Southeastern Minnesota, to the grand estates on the banks of Lake Geneva, Michael Bentley has had a lifelong passion for the land and people of this beautiful area. He began managing the Black Point Estate in Lake Geneva 26 years ago, when he founded House Check, Inc. He and Peggy joined Keefe Real Estate in 2003.


Peggy Bentley

Born and raised in the rural Milwaukee area, Peggy Bentley grew up showing horses and having fun at her family’s Delavan lakefront home. After attended UW-Lacrosse and studying Biology, she spent 15 years as a surgical technician, and then helped found House Check, Inc. with Michael. Together they have managed many prominent Lake Geneva Estates, and now bring that insider knowledge to Team Bentley Real Estate.